Chris Tepedino is a feature writer that has written extensively about car insurance for numerous websites. He has a college degree in communication from the University of Tennessee and has experience reporting, research investigative pieces…

Full Bio →

Written by

Rachael Brennan has been working in the insurance industry since 2006 when she began working as a licensed insurance representative for 21st Century Insurance, during which time she earned her Property and Casualty license in all 50 states…

Full Bio →

Reviewed byRachael Brennan
Licensed Insurance Agent for 14 Years

UPDATED: Jul 18, 2020

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Are you in need of cheap auto insurance in Buffalo, NY? With, you will find the most affordable insurance rates in your city. To get free car insurance rates from the top providers now, provide your local zip code into the quote box in this posting. Buffalo, located on the eastern side of Lake Erie, is the second biggest city in all of New York and also the biggest inland port. Buffalo was awarded the “All-American City” title by the National Civic League in 2002, but has since faced problems from negative public perception and an unfortunate decline in population. However, it still maintains notoriety for its beautiful parkland and stunning local architecture.

  • Fun fact: what was that strange noise? Because Buffalo is #5 on the list of “Top 100 cities with oldest houses (pop. 50,000+)” Learn a little more about Buffalo by visiting here.

Auto Insurance Coverage Requirements in New York

Driving legally in Buffalo requires:

CoverageRequirementsMost Common
Bodily Injury Liability25,000/50,000100,000/300,000
Property Damage Liability10,00050,000
Uninsured Motorist Bodily Injury25,000/50,00025,000/50,000
Medical PaymentsNot required100,000
CollisionNot required500 deductible
ComprehensiveNot required500 deductible

Keep in mind that whether you decide to go with the state minimum coverage, or to purchase more, will depend on the vehicle you are insuring. Older, less expensive cars can get away with a bare minimum policy. Newer vehicles, especially those that are still being financed, will need more coverage. Average insurance rates will vary between drivers, but the average cost is around $98 per month. However, if you live in Buffalo, there are some deals available now in your area which could lower your monthly premiums to $70/mo* or less. We’ll show you how.

Average Monthly Auto Insurance Premiums Legend: Buffalo Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120 135 $59 $64 $70 $136 $134

  Amica, Allstate, and Central Mutual are all trying to offer the lowest premiums in Buffalo right now. But keep in mind, however, that these are for the average driver. Certain companies specialize in certain groups of drivers, and their monthly rates may fluctuate wildly if your personal circumstances fall into one of these “outlier” groups. New York auto insurance carriers consider many variables when determining insurance rates, such as driving experience, driving violations, occupation, driving distance to work, and business use of the vehicle. Also, premiums might vary from one company to another. To discover if you are still paying a reasonably affordable price, assess cheap Buffalo auto insurance costs on the internet.

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Major Car Insurance Factors in Buffalo

There is a variety of various things which could factor into the rate quotes you are offered. Although many specific issues aren’t actually anything you can do something about, a few of them are elements that you can change for the better. Here are some components which may change your automobile insurance premium:

Your Zip Code

Your auto insurance rates may vary depending on where you live. Generally, large cities feature greater auto insurance rates as the additional amount of drivers on the highway raises the chance of an accident! The total population of Buffalo amounts to 258,959 and the general household earnings are $32,392.

Auto Insurance by Zip Code Legend: Buffalo New York Rochester Syracuse Yonkers Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 $59 $125 $37 $42 $67 $64 $102 $56 $50 $57 $70 $135 $39 $41 $70 $136 $186 $64 $62 $85 $134 $281 $84 $100 $170


Automotive Accidents

For nearly having a quarter of a million residents, some might expect to see more serious accidents in the Buffalo area than what is present in the chart above. The low number of accidents should be automatically lowering rates in your area – but if you are unsure, it would be best to get in touch with your local insurance agent.

Fatal Accidents in Buffalo, NY Legend: Buffalo Fatal accident count Vehicles involved in fatal crashes Fatal crashes involving drunk persons Fatalities Persons involved in fatal crashes Pedestrians involved in fatal accidents 2 4 6 8 10 12 7 10 7 12 3


Auto Thefts in Buffalo

The size of your city and its crime rate statistics, especially in relation to auto theft, will have a significant effect on how your provider calculates your auto insurance rate. Larger cities and/or cities with higher rates of car theft will raise your premiums, generally. But if you install a passive anti-theft system, this will usually lower your costs. Within Buffalo, they had 957 auto thefts in the year 2013. Theft numbers are dropping, but they are still a little high. Protect yourself from theft with Comprehensive coverage on your policy.

Basic vs. Comprehensive Auto Policy Legend: Basic Coverage Comprehensive Coverage Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 $59 $165 $64 $109 $70 $199 $136 $216 $134 $255


Your Credit Score

Suffering from poor credit? Well, unfortunately, your insurance premiums will only complicate the issue. Many companies in New York charge exceptionally high rates for poor credit – although it appears as though Nationwide is giving some drivers a break.

Auto Insurance by Credit Score Legend: Excellent Credit Poor Credit Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 $59 $91 $55 $146 $66 $126 $110 $263 $120 $138


Your Age

Older drivers, because of their age and experience with driving, are much less likely to get into an accident. That is why, conversely, their young adult counterparts are charged much more for insurance. Be sure to ask about discounts for young drivers and students if you are one, or are trying to find insurance for one in your family.

Auto Policy Age Comparison Legend: 34 Year Old 17 Year Old Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 45 90 135 180 225 270 315 360 405 $59 $400 $64 $240 $70 $214 $136 $446 $134 $422


Your Driving Record

Most drivers on the road today don’t have a perfect record. For minor violations, such as a low-level accident, you might be able to get that factored out with an Accident Forgiveness policy, lowering your monthly premium. But more serious charges, like a DUI, could eliminate your coverage completely.

Driving Violations Legend: Perfect Record Minor speeding ticket DUI/Reckless Driving Major At-Fault Accident Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 15 30 45 60 75 90 105 120 135 150 165 180 $59 $82 $180 $59 $64 $75 $83 $64 $70 $70 Do Not Sell $70 $136 $151 $151 $136 $134 $153 $174 $134


Your Vehicle

The age and overall value of your vehicle will greatly determine how much coverage you need to purchase in order to protect it adequately – and this, in turn, determines how much you will pay for coverage each month.

Car Insurance by Make/Model Legend: 2015 Honda Accord 2012 Porcshe Boxster Spyder Amica Allstate Central Mutual State Farm Nationwide 35 70 105 140 175 210 245 280 315 350 $59 $178 $64 $130 $70 $210 $136 $237 $134 $350


Minor Car Insurance Factors in Buffalo

The factors below can be a little harder to control, but they can also raise or lower your monthly premium:

Your Marital Status

In general, there is very little difference between what married people and single people are charged for premiums. However, being bundled together on the same policy with your spouse can net you some exceptional discounts!

Your Gender

Most insurance companies can’t seem to decide what to charge male and female drivers. The vast majority of companies have stopped charging different rates based on gender altogether. However, those who still do rarely charge more than a 2-4% difference.

Your Driving Distance to Work

Commute times for motorists in Buffalo usually last between 17-24 full minutes, give or take about 5 minutes each trip. Around 65% of drivers will choose to take their own vehicle alone, while 2-8% will likely carpool. 10% typically take the bus. Did you know that insuring a business vehicle will up your premiums by over 10% each month? So try to avoid it if you can. Otherwise, your driving habits – such as yearly mileage, reasons for driving, etc. – will rarely fluctuate more than 3-5%, no matter how you change your behavior.

Your Coverage and Deductibles

Want to know about a quick and easy trick for lowering your monthly rate? Raise your deductible. But save a little money just in case. Because if you don’t pay that deductible first, your insurance company won’t pay out on any claims.

Education in Buffalo, NY

29% of residents in Syracuse have achieved their high school diploma or a similar equivalent. Meanwhile, 24% have yet to complete all four years of high school. And speaking of education, there’s something all Syracuse motorists should know: the further you take your education, the more money you can save on your auto insurance policy! It’s even better than what you might get for having a prestigious job, or a high salary. Nearly 50 different educational institutions service the Syracuse area, educating over 215,000 students each year. Syracuse University offers bachelors and graduate degrees from 13 different colleges, and LeMoyne College is a private university affiliated with the Catholic Church. SUNY also operates a medical school in Syracuse. For those who would prefer to spend less time in school, there is the Onondaga Community College, or Cayuga Community College. Ascertaining your own personal financial risk can be very challenging or inconceivable for the common insurance shopper. Insurance providers have got an advantage over shoppers due to their research and experiential expertise. Discover the things that insurance providers don’t really want anyone to learn.

How We Conducted Our Car Insurance Analysis

*We calculated our average rate based on the following metrics: a married, 34 year old male with good credit, a 12-month history of maintaining auto insurance, a clean driving record, who owns his own home. Miles driven annually were based on the national average. The average rate was also calculated based on a financed 2015 Honda Accord with a pre-installed anti-theft device. Sources: New York Department of Financial Services New York Department of Financial Services – Insurance Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles

Enter your zip code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

All set to compare rates? Learn how much you will save!