Allstate vs. Nationwide: Best Auto Insurance for 2021

A comparison of Allstate vs. Nationwide auto insurance rates shows that Nationwide is the cheaper option. Allstate auto insurance has a bigger market share and fewer NAIC complaints, but Nationwide auto insurance rates are $120 less expensive per month on average. Allstate vs. Nationwide auto insurance quotes will vary based on factors specific to you.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Chris Tepedino is a feature writer that has written extensively about auto insurance for numerous websites. He has a college degree in communication from the University of Tennessee and has experience reporting, researching investigative pieces, and crafting detailed, data-driven features. His works have been featured on CB Blog Nation, Flow Words, Healing Law, WIBW Kansas, and ...

Full Bio →

Written by

Rachael Brennan has been working in the insurance industry since 2006 when she began working as a licensed insurance representative for 21st Century Insurance, during which time she earned her Property and Casualty license in all 50 states. After several years she expanded her insurance expertise, earning her license in Health and AD&D insurance as well. She has worked for small health in...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Rachael Brennan
Licensed Insurance Agent Rachael Brennan

UPDATED: Jul 19, 2021

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We partner with top insurance providers. This doesn’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Can't-Miss Facts

  • Allstate Insurance has a larger market share and earns more than Nationwide Insurance
  • Nationwide auto insurance rates are about $100 cheaper than Allstate auto insurance
  • You can save money when bundling Nationwide Pet Insurance or Nationwide Retirement with an auto insurance policy
  • Allstate’s financial strength ratings are much stronger than Nationwide’s ratings

Now that you’ve narrowed your auto insurance list to Allstate and Nationwide, you’re ready to compare Allstate vs. Nationwide auto insurance rates. However, your auto insurance is determined by several factors.

Our Allstate vs. Nationwide auto insurance guide explains everything you need to know about their monthly auto insurance rates, coverage options, discounts, and third-party ratings.

Before learning all about Allstate vs. Nationwide, enter your ZIP code in the free comparison tool above to compare multiple companies in your area.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance: Which company is the cheapest?

On average, Nationwide auto insurance is $120 cheaper than Allstate auto insurance. Do lower prices make Nationwide the better company? Not necessarily.

Let’s examine a quick summary of both companies. This will give you an idea of where Allstate and Nationwide stand in the car insurance industry.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Summary
SummaryAllstate Auto Insurance StatsNationwide Auto Insurance Stats
Year Founded19311926
Headquarters3075 Sanders Road Northbrook, IL 60062-7127One West Nationwide Blvd. Columbus, OH 43215-2220
Phone Number1-877-366-16071-877-669-6877
Direct Premiums$23.8 Billion$6.6 Billion
Market Share9%3%
National Average Auto Insurance$407/month$287/month
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Allstate earns $17.2 billion more than Nationwide. Also, Nationwide’s market share is six percent less than Allstate’s.

As a company, Allstate has a better financial standing. Earnings and market share don’t explain how well Allstate claims or Nationwide claims are paid out, but Allstate may be more efficient at paying claims.

If you want to learn the specifics about Allstate and Nationwide, read our Allstate Review or Nationwide Auto Insurance Review for more information. To compare Allstate vs. Nationwide car insurance based on various factors, continue reading.

Which is cheapest by driving record?

You can secure more affordable auto insurance if you maintain a clean driving record. Car insurance companies across the United States reward good drivers with cheaper rates because they’re less risky to insure.

So how do Allstate and Nationwide evaluate risk based on driving records? Take a look at Allstate vs. Nationwide auto insurance quotes based on driving record.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Rates by Driving Records
Driving Record SummaryAllstate Monthly Auto Insurance RatesNationwide Monthly Auto Insurance Rates
Clean Driving Record$318$229
With 1 Speeding Violation$374$259
With 1 Accident$416$283
With 1 DUI$522$379
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Accidents and DUIs generate expensive car insurance rates while speeding tickets have the least impact. Overall, Nationwide auto insurance is less costly.

Which is cheapest by credit score?

Did you know car insurance companies use your credit score to determine your risk level? According to Experian, auto insurance providers correlate your credit score to the chance of filing claims.

Therefore, a good credit score means cheaper car insurance, and a poor credit score can increase your rates. Do Allstate and Nationwide follow this trend? Let’s find out.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Rates by Credit Scores
Credit History SummaryAllstate Monthly Auto Insurance RatesNationwide Monthly Auto Insurance Rates
Good Credit (670-739)$322$244
Fair Credit Score (580-669)$382$271
Poor Credit Score (300-579)$541$340
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Customers with good credit pay the least, while customers with fair and poor credit pay the most. If you have fair or poor credit, your best option would be Nationwide.

Which is cheapest by age, gender, and marital status?

One of the most significant factors to auto insurance is your age. Car insurance companies estimate rates based on age because it correlates to your driving experience.

Gender determines the risk. Statistically, male drivers take more risks than females. Marital status is about the same. How so? Married drivers are statistically less risky.

How do Allstate and Nationwide calculate auto insurance based on these factors? Let’s check out the cost of auto insurance based on age, gender, and marital status.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Rates by Age, Gender, and Marital Status
Age, Gender, and Marital StatusAllstate Monthly Auto Insurance RatesNationwide Monthly Auto Insurance Rates
Married 60-year-old female$243$178
Married 60-year-old male$249$185
Married 35-year-old male$260$199
Married 35-year-old female$263$197
Single 25-year-old female$285$224
Single 25-year-old male$298$241
Single 17-year-old female$774$480
Single 17-year-old male$887$598
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Nationwide car insurance is still cheaper than Allstate car insurance. Married drivers pay more affordable car insurance rates, while single drivers pay more.

Any teen driver added to your policy drives up your rates, too. However, student discounts and multi-driver discounts can bring those rates down.

Which is cheapest by commute mileage?

If you reduce the miles you drive per year you can save money on your car insurance. Some auto insurance companies provide discounts to customers who drive less.

Why? Driving less lowers your chance of getting into an accident and filing a claim. The more you drive, the more your auto insurance company will charge you. But how much more will you pay? Let’s examine Allstate and Nationwide’s response to commute mileage.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Rates by Commute Mileage
Estimated Commute MileageAllstate Monthly Auto Insurance RatesNationwide Monthly Auto Insurance Rates
10 Miles Commute (6,000 miles/yr)$403$286
25 Miles Commute (12,000 miles/yr)$411$289
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Allstate is more expensive than Nationwide, but other circumstances would decrease your overall auto insurance quote. The increase from 6,000 to 12,000 miles per year is more cost-efficient to get the highest commute mileage available.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance: Which company has more coverage options?

Why are coverage options important? If you’re financing a vehicle, you may need more than just liability coverage. Lower prices can open the opportunity for you to pick up more coverage.

What coverage options are available at Allstate and Nationwide? Let’s compare them.

Comparing Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Coverage Options
Allstate Auto Insurance CoveragesNationwide Auto Insurance Coverages
Collision coverageBodily Injury Liability
Comprehensive coverageProperty Damage Liability
Bodily Injury LiabilityMedical Payments coverage
Property Damage LiabilityCollision coverage
Uninsured & Underinsured Motorist CoverageComprehensive coverage
Rental Reimbursement CoverageUninsured & Underinsured Motorist Coverage
Personal Umbrella PolicyPersonal Injury Protection
Personal Injury ProtectionGAP Coverage
Sound System InsuranceRental Car Expense
Roadside AssistanceRoadside Assistance
Classic Car InsuranceAccident Forgiveness
Travel Car Insurance to MexicoVanishing Deductible
Total Loss Deductible Waiver
Towing and Labor Coverage
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Nationwide has more coverage options, but Allstate has sound system insurance, classic car insurance, and travel car insurance to Mexico. These exclusive options make each company more interesting. Weigh out your options and see which company is best for you.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance: Who has more discounts?

Getting a quote that was higher than expected can change if you’re eligible for discounts. Car insurance discounts lower your monthly rates to a manageable price and open your budget to more insurance opportunities if you need them.

Let’s compare Allstate and Nationwide discounts to see which company has more opportunities to save.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance Discounts
Auto Insurance DiscountsAllstate AvailabilityNationwide Availability
Adaptive Cruise Control
Adaptive Headlights
Anti-lock Brakes
Daytime Running Lights
Electronic Stability Control
Utility Vehicle
Vehicle Recovery
VIN Etching
Lane Departure Warning
Newer Vehicle
Green Vehicle
Forward Collision Warning
Claim Free
Continuous Coverage
Defensive Driver
Distant Student
Driver's Ed
Driving Device/App
Early Signing
Emergency Deployment
Engaged Couple
Family Legacy
Family Plan
Farm Vehicle
Fast 5
Federal Employee
Full Payment
Further Education
Good Credit
Good Student
Life Insurance
Low Mileage
Military Garaging
Multiple Drivers
Multiple Policies
Multiple Vehicles
New Address
New Customer/New Plan
New Graduate
Newly Licensed
Occasional Operator
On-Time Payments
Online Shopper
Paperless Documents
Paperless/Auto Billing
Passive Restraint
Recent Retirees
Roadside Assistance
Safe Driver
Seat Belt Use
Senior Driver
Stable Residence
Students & Alumni
Switching Provider
Young Driver
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

Nationwide wins the discount battle by providing six more discounts than Allstate. However, it’s not likely you’ll qualify for all the bargains that a car insurance company has to offer. With enough discounts, you can lower Allstate auto insurance rates close to Nationwide’s average rate.

Bundling policies can help as well. For example, Nationwide customers can bundle Nationwide Pet Insurance with their auto insurance to save money. Although it doesn’t save you money, products like Nationwide retirement services can keep everything in one place.

Which company has the better financial strength and customer satisfaction ratings?

Before you buy auto insurance, take the time to look at a company’s financial strength and customer satisfaction ratings. What are those? Financial strength and credit ratings show how well a company manages money and how it responds to customers.

Several agencies conduct studies each year and sum up the performance of insurance companies.

The most reliable agencies for financial strength and credit ratings are AM Best, Moody’s, and S&P. For customer satisfaction, J.D. Power, Consumer Reports, and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).

We compiled the ratings of each agency below. Let’s examine Allstate and Nationwide’s third-party ratings.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Financial Strength and Credit Ratings
AgenciesAllstate RatingsNationwide Ratings
AM BestA+A+
NAIC Complaint Index0.411.45
J.D. Power - Power Circle RatingsAbout AverageAbout Average
Consumer Reports8888
iOS App Rating5 stars2 stars
Android App Rating4 stars3 stars
Get Your Rates Quote Now

Compare RatesStart Now →

With A.M. Best, Allstate and Nationwide have the same score. However, Nationwide has a better Moody’s credit score. Allstate makes a comeback with an even better S&P credit score.

Allstate is the better company in terms of customer satisfaction. The NAIC Complaint Index shows a complaint ratio within a year and Allstate scores under the average.

Allstate and Nationwide have the same score under J.D. Power and Consumer Reports, but Allstate has more substantial mobile app ratings. Allstate’s app can be used to file a claim, as can Nationwide’s.

If you want to access the apps for either company, you’ll need to create a Nationwide or an Allstate insurance account. You can create a Nationwide or Allstate login online or on your smartphone.

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance: Pros & Cons

Let’s go over a few advantages and disadvantages of both companies.

  • Nationwide Pros
    • Provides cheaper rates
    • More coverage options
  • Nationwide Cons
    • Weak customer reviews
    • Lower market share and earning potential
  • Allstate Pros
    • Strong customer reviews
    • Provides rideshare insurance
  • Allstate Cons
    • Higher premiums
    • Fewer discount opportunities

Did we miss something? Revisit some of the sections above to double-check which company is best.

Allstate vs. Nationwide Auto Insurance: The Bottom Line

Ultimately, Nationwide is the cheaper company, but Allstate is much better with customers. However, when you compare auto insurance for yourself, your quotes could be different.

There’s a lot to think about when comparing Allstate vs. Nationwide. In the meantime, shop around. Enter your ZIP code to find quotes in your local area.

Free Auto Insurance Comparison

Enter your ZIP code below to compare auto insurance rates.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption